Fashion Nova Halloween Costumes 2024: Honest Reviews, Pros, Cons, and Sizing

Published on October 9, 2023

Thinking about getting a Halloween costume from Fashion Nova this year? Sierra Schultzzie and her friend Jaden tried out some of Fashion Nova's Halloween costumes for 2024 to see how good they really are. They shared what they liked, what they didn't, and a few funny moments along the way. Keep reading to find out if these costumes are worth your time and money.

Key Points from the Video Reviews

Comfort: Comfort can be hit or miss. Some costumes are surprisingly comfy, like the "Hot In Here Firefighter" set, but others, like the "Sassy Strawberry," are itchy and tight.
Quality vs. Price: Quality changes a lot between costumes, and some might not be worth the price. The "Pink Wednesdays Regina George" set was disappointing for $62.99, while others were a better deal.
Fit and Sizing: Sizing can be unpredictable. Some costumes fit well, but others, like the "Toy Story Alien," had big problems, especially for plus sizes.
Creativity: The designs are creative, but sometimes the execution isn't great. Costumes like the "Sexy Strawberry" and "Toy Story Alien" were fun, but they didn't always meet expectations.

Products Mentioned

Are Fashion Nova Halloween Costumes Comfortable to Wear?

Key takeaway: Comfort can be hit or miss. Sierra starts by talking about the “Hot In Here Firefighter” costume, which was actually more comfortable than expected. The material was breathable, and the fit was good. Jaden rated it 8.8/10. Sierra liked the zipper, saying, "It's easy, it's recognizable, and it doesn't stick to your skin the way I thought it might." On the other hand, some costumes, like the Sassy Strawberry set, were not comfortable at all. Sierra said, "It's itchy and it's tight."

Ahyanna Chardae also had mixed feelings about the Keep It Cruel costume, inspired by Cruella de Vil. She loved the style and details but found the material itchy: "I don't know what fabric that is in here, but it is a little itchy, but I mean it's workable."

Pros: Some costumes, like the firefighter one, are surprisingly comfortable.

Cons: Some materials are itchy, and sizing can be inconsistent.

Is Fashion Nova Halloween Costume Quality Worth the Price?

Key takeaway: Quality is all over the place, and it might not be worth the price. The Pink Wednesdays Regina George set left Sierra disappointed, especially for $62.99. "Honestly, this is the biggest ripoff," she said. The shirt and skirt were awkwardly attached, and the rhinestones looked stretched. Sierra summed it up: "Where did the rest of my costume go?"

Ahyanna’s thoughts on the Got The Juice Beetlejuice-inspired costume were also mixed. She liked the overall look but didn't like the wig: "I don't like the wig, but you know just for this purpose, I had to show y'all what it looks like." The costume had potential, but the accessories fell short.

Pros: Some costumes come with nice accessories like hats, gloves, and necklaces.

Cons: The materials can feel cheap, and you could easily make something similar from a thrift store for less money.

How Do Fashion Nova Halloween Costumes Fit? Are They True to Size?

Key takeaway: Sizing varies a lot from costume to costume. Sierra and Jaden both tried the Toy Story Alien costume. It was really tight, and the fishnets even ripped. Jaden asked, "Do I have a long torso, or did they make the plus-size version with different dimensions?" This wasn’t the first time they noticed differences in sizing between regular and plus-size options.

Ahyanna also struggled with sizing in the Little Miss Ivy Poison Ivy costume. She said the dress was shorter than expected: "I probably would have gone with a small medium, but I got it wrong, and that's all that matters." She had to make some adjustments to feel comfortable.

Pros: Some costumes, like the firefighter one, fit well and are adjustable.

Cons: Inconsistent sizing can lead to awkward fits—like feeling "trapped and exposed" in the strawberry costume.

How Creative Are Fashion Nova's Halloween Costumes in 2024?

Key takeaway: Creativity is hit or miss, and accessories help but don’t always save the costume. The firefighter costume was simple but effective, while the sexy strawberry was more funny than practical. Sierra rated the strawberry an 8/10 because it was fun, but she wasn’t sure about the quality: "This feels like how I'd imagine a Truffula Tree feels." Accessories like belts, hats, and headbands can add to the look, but sometimes they feel mismatched.

Ahyanna reviewed the Go Team Cheerleader costume, inspired by the Dallas Cowboys cheerleader outfit. She liked the details, like the stars, but wished it had pom-poms: "That's the only thing about this. I do wish it came with pom-poms, but that's fine. You can find those anywhere." The Want to Play Bloody Evil Doll costume was also a mixed bag—it came with a wig and socks, but the overall look felt a bit cheap.

Pros: The ideas are creative, like a sexy strawberry or an alien, and they bring in some nostalgia.

Cons: The execution doesn’t always match the concept. For example, the "pink on Wednesdays" tagline for Regina George wasn’t very memorable.

Our Editorial Take on the Fashion Nova Costume Review

Sierra and Jaden’s chemistry makes their review fun and easy to watch. They mix humor with honest opinions, which makes the try-on experience enjoyable. Sierra’s funny comparisons, like saying the pink fabric felt like goggles at a pool, made the review easy to follow. Their honesty was refreshing—you can tell they’re not trying to sell anything; they're just having fun with these costumes.

Ahyanna Chardae’s review also brings a lot of excitement with real criticism. Her love for Halloween is obvious, and her honest reactions to each costume make the review fun to watch. Ahyanna’s honesty about the problems—like itchy materials and weird wigs—makes the review feel genuine.

A Verdict Worth Considering: If you want a creative costume on a budget and don’t mind some ups and downs in quality and comfort, Fashion Nova could be an option. Just be ready to make some DIY improvements or "adjust the fit so I can actually breathe," as Sierra said.

Shopping With Trust and Haute

Want to buy Halloween costumes and more without worrying if it’s a trick or a treat? Haute is here for you! With custom recommendations, we make online shopping super easy. Plus, we bring different brands together so you can make the best choices—less costume drama, more costume fun!

Check out the full video reviews by Sierra Schultzzie here and Ahyanna Chardae here.